| NFHL All-NFHL Teams | |||||||
| Year | Forward | Forward | Forward | Defense | Defense | Goalie | |
| 1993 | 1st Team |
 Michel Goulet Buffalo Sabres |
 Doug Gilmour Toronto Maple Leafs |
 Glenn Anderson Toronto Maple Leafs |
 Don Sweeney Winnipeg Jets |
 Steve Konroyd Detroit Red Wings |
 Kelly Hrudey Colorado Rockies |
| 2nd Team |
 Laurie Boschman Buffalo Sabres |
 Mario Tremblay Colorado Rockies |
 Steve Thomas Buffalo Sabres |
 Chris Chelios Toronto Maple Leafs |
 Paul Coffey Hartford Whalers |
 Dominik Hasek Toronto Maple Leafs |
|
| 1992 | 1st Team | Wayne Gretzky (WAS) | Steve Yzerman (COL) | Mark Messier (WAS) | Craig Muni (COL) | Larry Murphy (TOR) | Dominik Hasek (TOR) |
| 2nd Team | Glenn Anderson (TOR) | Denis Savard (BUF) | Pat Lafontaine (TOR) | Al MacInnis (WIN) | Paul Coffey (HAR) | Kelly Hrudey (COL) | |
| 1991 | 1st Team | Glenn Anderson (TOR) | Mario Tremblay (COL) | Jari Kurri (EDM) | Phil Housley (BUF) | James Patrick (TOR) | Dominik Hasek (TOR) |
| 2nd Team | Adam Oates (HAR) | Dale Hawerchuk (ANA) | Mike Bossy (TOR) | Ray Bourque (HAR) | Mike O'Connell (WAS) | Tom Barasso (EDM) | |
| 1990 | 1st Team | Wayne Gretzky (EDM) | Mario Tremblay (COL) | Jari Kurri (EDM) | Paul Coffey (EDM) | Larry Murphy (TOR) | Denis Herron (COL) |
| 2nd Team | Peter Stastny (COL) | Steve Yzerman (COL) | Ron Francis (COL) | Craig Muni (COL) | Jim Wiemer (NYI) | Allan Bester (WIN) | |
| 1989 | 1st Team | Wayne Gretzky (EDM) | Mario Tremblay (COL) | Daryl Evans (MON) | Ray Bourque (QUE) | Al MacInnis (NYR) | Doug Soetaert (NYI) |
| 2nd Team | Michel Goulet (NYI) | Gerard Gallant (WIN) | Steve Thomas (WIN) | John Glynne (EDM) | Fred Boimistruck (BUF) | Tom Barasso (EDM) | |
| 1988 | 1st Team | Wayne Gretzky (EDM) | Steve Larmer (EDM) | Guy Lafleur (NYI) | Larry Murphy (COL) | Craig Hartsburg (NYI) | Doug Soetaert (NYI) |
| 2nd Team | Laurie Boschman (BUF) | Guy Chouinard (NYI) | Marcel Dionne (CHI) | Paul Coffey (EDM) | Al MacInnis (NYR) | Don Beaupre (HAR) | |
| 1987 | 1st Team | Adam Oates (HAR) | Sergei Makarov (PIT) | Pierre Larouche (PIT) | Tapio Levo (COL) | Paul Coffey (EDM) | Don Edwards (WAS) |
| 2nd Team | Wayne Gretzky (EDM) | Dennis Maruk (WIN) | Marcel Dionne (CHI) | Ray Bourque (STL) | Peter Andersson (HAR) | Kelly Hrudey (COL) | |
| 1986 | 1st Team | Wayne Gretzky (EDM) | Peter Stastny (CGY) | Marcel Dionne (CHI) | Paul Coffey (EDM) | Dave Farrish (BUF) | Denis Herron (EDM) |
| 2nd Team | Mario Tremblay (COL) | Guy Chouinard (NYI) | Joe Mullen (MON) | Larry Robinson (NYI) | Val James (MON) | Don Edwards (PHI) | |
| 1985 | 1st Team | Wayne Gretzky (EDM) | Peter Stastny (CGY) | Pierre Larouche (PHI) | Bobby Orr (NYI) | Dale Tallon (PHI) | Doug Soetaert (NYI) |
| 2nd Team | Darryl Sittler (CGY) | Mike Gartner (BUF) | Jari Kurri (EDM) | Tomas Jonsson (MON) | Al MacInnis (NYR) | Mike Palmateer (WIN) | |
| 1984 | 1st Team | Mario Tremblay (COL) | Dennis Maruk (WIN) | Joe Mullen (HAR) | Tapio Levo (COL) | Jocelyn Guevremont (MIN) | Mike Palmateer (WIN) |
| 2nd Team | Rod SHutt (DET) | Peter Stastny (CGY) | Gilbert Perreault (PHI) | Larry Robinson (PHI) | Mike O'Connell (DET) | Denis Herron (COL) | |
| 1983 | 1st Team | Guy Lafleur (NYI) | Lanny McDonald (MIN) | Reggie LEach (DET) | Guy Lapointe (NYI) | Jocelyn Guevremont (MIN) | Doug Soetaert (NYI) |
| 2nd Team | Paul Holmgren (DET) | Dennis Maruk (WIN) | Guy CHouinard (NYI) | Ron Greschner (COL) | Tapio Levo (COL) | Denis Herron (COL) | |
| 1982 | 1st Team | Darryl Sittler (TOR) | Steve Shutt (PHI) | Reggie Leach (DET) | Jim Schoenfeld (EDM) | Randy Carlyle (MON) | Don Edwards (PHI) |
| 2nd Team | Guy Lafleur (NYI) | Jacques Richard (PHI) | Bryan Trottier (PHI) | Jocelyn Guevremont (MIN) | Dale Tallon (PHI) | Doug Soetaert (NYI) | |
| 1981 | 1st Team | Rod Shutt (DET) | Michel Goulet (CAL) | Steve Shutt (PHI) | Larry Robinson (TOR) | Jocelyn Guevremont (MIN) | Michel Larocque (DET) |
| 2nd Team | Darryl Sittler (TOR) | Reggie Leach (DET) | Bryan Trottier (PHI) | Ron Greschner (COL) | Brad Selwood (EDM) | Mike Palmateer (WIN) | |
| 1980 | 1st Team | Kent Nilsson (WIN) | Steve Shutt (PHI) | Guy Lafleur (MON) | Bobby Orr (CGY) | Jocelyn Guevremont (MIN) | Mike Palmateer (WIN) |
| 2nd Team | Peter Stastny (CGY) | Rick Martin (MON) | Gilbert Perreault (PHI) | Serge Savard (CAL) | Mike O'Connell (DET) | Vladislav Tretiak (MIN) | |
| 1979 | 1st Team | Bobby Clarke (BOS) | Denis Dupere (MIN) | Serge Bernier (COL) | Jocelyn Guevremont (MIN) | Tom Edur (CGY) | Billy Smith (MON) |
| 2nd Team | Marc Tardif (NYR) | Phil Esposito (CGY) | Guy Lafleur (MON) | Fred Barrett (MIN) | Larry Robinson (MON) | Don Edwards (PHI) | |
| 1978 | 1st Team | Darryl Sittler (TOR) | Billy Harris (CHI) | Dan Maloney (MIN) | Larry Robinson (MON) | Ab DeMarco (MON) | Michel Plasse (TOR) |
| 2nd Team | Gilbert Perreault (EDM) | Marc Tardif (MIN) | Jacque Lemaire (EDM) | Jocelyn Guevremont (MIN) | Brad Park (BOS) | Vladislav Tretiak (MIN) | |
| 1977 | 1st Team | Gilbert Perreault (EDM) | Marc Tardif (MIN) | Guy Lafleur (MON) | Larry Robinson (MON) | Brad Selwood (EDM) | Michel Plasse (MON) |
| 2nd Team | Darryl Sittler (TOR) | Dennis Maruk (WIN) | Marcel Dionne (CHI) | Alexander Gusev (CAL) | Bobby Orr (NYR) | Billy Smith (MIN) | |
| 1976 | 1st Team | Darryl Sittler (TOR) | Steve Shutt (MON) | Tom Webster (BOS) | Larry Robinson (MON) | Alexander Gusev (CAL) | Ken Dryden (PHI) |
| 2nd Team | Guy Lafleur (MON) | Bobby Sheehan (CHI) | Marcel Dionne (CHI) | Denis Potvin (CHI) | Bobby Orr (PHI) | Billy Smith (MIN) | |
| 1975 | 1st Team | Darryl Sittler (TOR) | Marc Tardif (MIN) | Marcel Dionne (CHI) | Brad Selwood (EDM) | Bobby Orr (PHI) | Al Smith (STL) |
| 2nd Team | Gilbert Perreault (EDM) | Claude Larose (PIT) | Alexander Maltsev (TOR) | Serge Savard (PHI) | Alexander Gusev (CAL) | Bernie Parent (PIT) | |
| 1974 | 1st Team | Phil Esposito (PHI) | Hilliard Graves (LAK) | Gilbert Perreault (EDM) | Brad Selwood (EDM) | Serge Savard (PIT) | Gilles Meloche (BOS) |
| 2nd Team | Jean Pronovost (EDM) | Valery Kharlamov (LAK) | Tom Webster (BOS) | Bobby Orr (PHI) | Alexander Gusev (CAL) | Vladislav Tretiak (CAL) | |
| 1973 | 1st Team | Phil Esposito (TOR) | Pete Mahovlich (TOR) | Paul Henderson (TOR) | Ron Stackhouse (DET) | Dale Tallon (CAL) | Vladislav Tretiak (CAL) |
| 2nd Team | Walt Tkaczuk (QUE) | Dennis Hextall (PIT) | Gilbert Perreault (EDM) | Jerry Korab (QUE) | Alexander Gusev (CAL) | Denis Herron (EDM) | |
| 1972 | 1st Team | Darryl Sittler (DET) | Garry Unger (PHI) | Mickey Redmond (DET) | Bobby Orr (BOS) | JC Tremblay (STL) | Vladislav Tretiak (CAL) |
| 2nd Team | Walt Tkaczuk (PHI) | Vic Hadfield (CHI) | Gilbert Perreault (EDM) | Brad Selwood (EDM) | Ron Stackhouse (DET) | Gary Smith (NYR) | |
| 1971 | 1st Team | Phil Esposito (NYR) | Bobby Hull (NYR) | Guy Lafleur (MON) | Bobby Orr (BOS) | Fred Barrett (MIN) | Ken Dryden (MON) |
| 2nd Team | Yvon Cournoyer (MON) | Valery Kharlmaov (LAK) | Ken Hodge (VAN) | Brad Selwood (EDM) | Tim Horton (ATL) | Gerry Desjardins (MON) | |